The Sontaran Stratagem

DVD NTSC
Region 1
14-episode
box set

DVD PAL
Region 2
14-episode
box set
DVD PAL
Region 2
4-episode volume
(Doctor Who Story No. 197, starring David Tennant)
  • written by Helen Raynor
  • directed by Douglas MacKinnon
  • produced by Susie Liggat
  • music by Murray Gold
  • 2 episodes @ 44 minutes each:
    1. The Sontaran Stratagem
    2. The Poison Sky
Story: Dr. Martha Jones calls the Doctor and Donna back to England to help U.N.I.T. investigate the main factory producing the wildly popular ATMOS contraption enabling ordinary cars to produce zero emissions, cars which have also caused a number of mysterious deaths. What is the founder of the Rattigan Academy hiding? What secret atmospheric project are Luke Rattigan's students really working on? And what is the real stratagem of the Doctor's old enemies, the Sontarans?

DVD Extras (box sets only) include:

  • Episode One audio commentary by Dan Starkey (Commander Skorr), make-up artist Neill Gorton, and executive producer Julie Gardner.
  • Episode Two audio commentary by David Tennant (The Doctor), executive producer Russell T. Davies, and producer Susie Liggat.
  • Doctor Who Confidential featurette: Send in the Clones (12 min.) with Tennant, Davies, Liggat, Catherine Tate (Donna Noble),
    Freema Agyeman (Martha Jones), Ruari Mears (Clone), and special effects supervisor Danny Hargreaves.
  • Doctor Who Confidential featurette: Sontar-Ha! (12 min.) with Tennant, Davies, Liggat, Starkey, Gorton, Tate,
    Christopher Ryan (General Staal), writer Helen Raynor, stunt co-ordinator Tom Lucy, and choreographer Ailsa Berk.
  • Trailers & Promos

In-Depth Analysis Review

by Martin Izsak

WARNING: This review contains "SPOILERS", and is intended for those who have already seen the program.
To avoid the spoilers, read the Buyers' Guide version instead.


After much anticipation, the Sontarans are finally back on screen, in a fairly successful and enjoyable story that also manages to be UNIT's best showing of the decade. But despite many excellent story beats, action sequences, and emotional moments, this story also has a number of absolutely dreadful points as well, dragging down its otherwise healthy rating and making a possible excellent story into a lukewarm one.


The story's opening delivers a number of disappointments right off the bat. Up first is the character of Luke Rattigan, who never seems to work quite right on screen. Too much over-the-top arrogance, not enough charisma, elegance, or subtlety. Paired with a cliché reporter adversary, the story's first on-screen conflict feels like bad 1980's TV drama. This comes complete with "car action" that soaks its head in the river. Not anywhere near exciting (or original) enough to justify its cost in the budget; I'd much rather see that money put to the deepening of alien cultures in the show.

In the midst of this is revealed the voice of the larger enemy - and it's really not deep enough or gritty enough to compete well with past Sontaran vocalizations or inspire thoughts of evolution on the heavy gravity planet of Sontar Prime. The result is a little too close to regular human.

You'd think you would have seen the pre-title cliffhanger after that car stunt, but the story's hook continues to feature an intergalactic cell-phone call (ugh), during which the producers choose instead to emphasize with the cliffhanger the fact that Martha is bringing the Doctor "back to Earth", yet another of the early disappointments of the story. Firstly, the Doctor had only just made it away from Earth for the first time in five stories with his previous adventure, so a call back to Earth seems WAY too early and misguided to be interpreted as a good thing. Secondly, the Sontarans have too often been seen in mundane side-track plots on Earth instead of in their own natural spheres of influence out in the galaxy. Joy at getting a Sontaran story became diluted upon seeing that opportunities to witness battles with Rutans and other aliens over interstellar real estate was being substituted with a collaboration with the Rattigan Academy of Earth.... yeah, not so inspiring. The producers really shouldn't boast too loudly about that.

To be fair, we do get some companion & family dynamics we haven't seen before, and about half of those are truly nice scenes. And it is good to see more of Martha simply embracing her role in the show, as it increases the return on our overly-lengthy investment getting her up to speed last season. But we're still stuck anticipating more of the same with Donna all over again, whether the angle turns out to have any fresh new bits or not. The TARDIS's journeys in New Millennium Doctor Who have become too centered around predictable annual companion arcs, and I found myself feeling resigned to being stuck on Earth going through more of the same motions for two more episodes.

I found it encouraging to see Freema Agyeman's name in the main title sequence (perhaps being the real reason why the titles had been delayed until after she was revealed), but I was more surprised to see that the writing of the story had been assigned to Helen Raynor. After last year's disastrously disappointing "Evolution of the Daleks" (story no. 186), I wouldn't have expected her to get what should be an important two-parter for this season. Thankfully, this Sontaran adventure is a vast improvement on her previous effort. And perhaps also due to her previous tendency to paint-by-numbers in constructing her story, we get a full and proper TARDIS materialization to start things off right. Good one.

UNIT is then revealed, and is yet another roster of completely new names and faces. The magic and charm of the UNIT cast in the 70's still doesn't seem to be recognized as the most important ingredient justifying the organization's return to our screens. But on the other hand, at least now Martha is a familiar part of that roster, and Colonel Mace and his sidekicks seem to be successful enough to be worthy of a return. I suppose we now have to hold our breath to see if that will ever happen.


If one can retain an open mind after the opening salvo of disappointments, one notices "The Sontaran Stratagem" getting better and better as it settles in. Right at the 10 minute mark, it hits the excellent sci-fi stride of exploring the unknown, using minor UNIT soldiers maybe, but at least ones who have some attained some skill from their training. And it should be creepy enough to keep horror-bent fans happy, while working well on other levels if that's not your thing.

The investigation of Rattigan's lab seems a bit short and, at the time, almost superfluous to the discoveries ultimately made. A pity, as lab scenes can often contain the heart of a story's sci-fi premises, and this one throws away some opportunities with idle word-play instead. We also seem to get the exact same gratuitous balls of flame going up in the background of the lab as we did back in "Evolution of the Daleks". Still doesn't quite make sense, although if we really stretch our imagination and speculate, it may be more appropriate to the atmospheric manipulation technologies present here.

The Sontarans are revealed in stages, each stage having its own scene or sequence that works fairly well. The costumes are excellent, although the blue colour seems less interesting than the classic black seen in the classic series. Make-up is very VERY excellent, of course on par with anything modern Star Trek had recently done, and rivaling original Sontaran make-up successes from "The Time Warrior" (story no. 70) and "The Invasion of Time" (story no. 97). Perhaps in making facial expressions come through the mask so easily, one loses some of the sense of alienness. Then again, deeper, more menacing voices might have helped solve that, and Christopher Ryan gives such a good performance as General Staal, you wouldn't want to miss those subtleties. While I've got nothing against Sontarans being shorter than the average human, they MUST remain stocky and heavy-set, which seems to have been a challenge for actors as short as were cast in this story. I think it was also a mistake to let the script's dialogue fixate on their height as much as it did. Ah, well, that's a minor nit.

The Sontarans get some wonderful CG spacecraft in this story as well, showing how the classic smaller individual spheres relate to a mothership. Now that's more like it. Too bad the ships never really get anything significant to actually do in the story.

Of course, revisiting Donna's family means we get more of Bernard Cribbins as Donna's grandfather Wilfred Mott, which turns out to be a highlight worth the price of admission. Exquisite performance; just wonderful. And it's clear he's finally being written for properly, instead of just being tacked on in hindsight. He gets to introduce his name properly, and gets formally introduced to the Doctor. Excellent. And at this point, Donna's Mum is great fun extending the introductory gag.

The music for this particular story appears to be running on auto-pilot by now. Quite a number of previously established themes make a return, such as music for Donna, Martha, the Doctor, and UNIT.... typically new renditions that aren't any better or worse than the originals, probably simply reworked to hit better timing with the picture. Action cues feature a lot of nifty toe-tapping riffs that repeat a lot without really going anywhere or saying much, and can last for as many or as few bars as needed before swapping out to the next one whenever a mood switch is needed. Most sad is that the Sontarans receive only musical sound gimmicks like dark electronic tones, weird percussive bubbling, or excessive repeats of emotionally dead orchestral marching bars. At no point is there any of Murray Gold's usually excellent composition effort for them. Time to step aside; Peter Howell still rules where Sontaran music is concerned, having given them an entire musical identity back in the Colin Baker era adventure "The Two Doctors" (story no. 141).

Having largely redeemed itself after its opening disappointments, this fairly good first episode sinks to another low point as the cliffhanger comes along. The story point to the cliffhanger is good, but quality is dragged down firstly by the idea of the Sontarans new "football" style chant, which is just an awful, cringe-worthy idea to begin with, and secondly by the director's choice to make this particular cliffhanger build-up so long. In the end it lacks pace and punch, not so much increasing tension as just mucking around with what it's got until it dissipates, and then waiting around some more before cutting to the credits. Ay caramba! This does need to be tightened up, and it's not at all hard to figure out what parts should hit the cutting room floor first. Off with their "Sontar-Ha's"!

As is, we're left with a disappointing after-taste in our mouths for a week while we wait for the second half. Not smart.

Music by Murray Gold
"Doctor Who" (Season 30 Title version), and
"UNIT Rocks" are available on:
Audio CD - Doctor Who:
Original Music from "Series 4" (2008)

More info & buying options

"The Doctor Forever", and
alternate versions of "Martha's Theme"
and "Donna's Theme" are available on:
Audio CD - Doctor Who:
Original Music from "Series 3" (2007)

More info & buying options

"UNIT" & "The Doctor's Theme" are available on:
Audio CD - Doctor Who by Murray Gold
Silva Screen SILCD1224

More info & buying options

The second episode has some decent plot strategies, but insists on being slightly disappointing by mentioning better ones that don't get put into action. David Tennant and Catherine Tate ramble a little too fast through the scene in which their characters split up, obscuring their motives and making you wonder how much of the ensuing plot the Doctor planned in advance. Not as much as a later remark might have you think if you don't dig deep enough for meaning.

The Doctor never does intend for the Sontarans to move the TARDIS up to their spaceship, but once he knows it's there with Donna in it, he DOES intend for them to move it out of their busy control room and into an empty hall. Not sure why the Sontarans should assume that his remote control will be any less effective in retrieving it while it's out in the hall, but whatever.

Personally, I think I'd probably prefer to have seen the Doctor successfully using his TARDIS to go up to the Sontaran ship himself as he originally intended and have some decent scenes and interaction and perform his usual interference there. That said, having Donna do some stuff on her own has good merit as well. I'm not too keen on the cell-phone conversations though - it takes away from this show's uniqueness and makes it look like everything else on TV. A particular waste of time is having Donna sit in the TARDIS phoning her family, especially after having just left their house - I had little patience with that on first viewing, and it doesn't create much anticipation for quality scenes to come.

A lot of good, fairly solid story beats are achieved during ensuing escalations, including decent en-masse UNIT vs. Sontaran battles, and a control-room based stand-off, but the logic connecting these ideas is questionable. We can understand why UNIT wants to fire missiles at the Sontaran ship, and why the Sontarans should want to stop them, but why does the Doctor also want the missiles stopped so badly? "Starting an interstellar war" as he states is a moot point by that time. Open war is upon the Earth from Sontar already, and the choices for avoiding it are past. The Doctor is also a bit defeatist when sizing up the Earth forces, but thankfully Mace nails him with the correct comment that it is a "lack of faith" on his part.

And exactly how is this contingent of Sontarans protecting their operative by attacking UNIT? Perhaps it's best not to pull too hard at the threads holding this story's plot together....

The Luke Rattigan character finally seems to be worthy of being on-screen when getting responses to pulling a gun on people. No one takes him seriously, proving that there is no quick substitute for charisma and building solid relationships. Some good scenes, but was it was worth sitting through the drab build-up last episode?

One of the better aspects of this story is in its many and varied discussions of environmental topics, from car emissions to oil shortages, to clean air, to government control of the issues. Although never cleanly aligning this to the central conflict to create a stronger sense of who to root for and why, it does bring a lot of important issues to the surface and remind viewers that we need to remain vigilant in seeking better methods of taking care of ourselves and designing our lifestyles. Nice one.

The Doctor is very active towards the end, solving mysteries and problems and tying up the loose ends of the plot. Well done. His very last heroic task is not so brilliant, however. Trying to get the Sontarans to back down or he'll blow himself up with them??? DUMB! With a capital D! They're past backing down, which is obvious even before they so eloquently state it to him. The Doctor just backs himself into a corner with this idiotic plan, unwilling to carry out his threat. Gotta give them a choice? They made their choice when they hatched their plan for the Earth and carried it out. He should've rigged a delay on the thing and sent it up alone. Or, if you really want to negotiate, you need to offer the Sontarans something they can appreciate better than running home with no honour left at all. Not sure why Staal spends quite as much time talking with him as he does either - if they are so keen to die, you'd think they'd shoot him and take their chances with his ability to trigger the device. At any rate, the Doctor's success seems to be entirely out of his own wimpy hands at that point, requiring a sacrificial side character to do his thing instead. We've seen this dynamic too often on Doctor Who before to make it anything special, and it's just as disappointing now as it ever was before. Was it really worth adding Luke's death to his conscience? I'd have preferred the Doctor to have retained the pro-active hand during this sequence.


Well, "The Sontaran Stratagem" turns out to be a likeable story in the end, and it grows on me especially after knowing what is in store for the rest of the season. I'd say it's better than "Aliens of London" (story no. 164) and "Evolution of the Daleks" which both occupied this slot in previous years, without really being able to rival the epic classic "Rise of the Cybermen" (story no. 176). It might have beaten "Planet of the Ood" (story no. 196) more easily as best story of the season proper so far if only it hadn't committed quite so many bad moves; as it stands the two stories are on fairly equal footing, while "The Fires of Pompeii" (story no. 195) gets better at challenging the pair of them as it ages. And I think "The Time Warrior" still stands as the best Sontaran story in Doctor Who. But Season 30 is still only just getting warmed up. Wait until you see what's next....



This story has become available on DVD.
Click on the Amazon symbol for the location nearest you for pricing and availability:

DVD NTSC Region 1
14-episode boxed set
for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
DVD PAL Region 2
14-episode boxed set
for the U.K.
DVD PAL Region 2
4-episode volume
U.K. format only

Note: The full season sets contain commentaries, behind-the-scenes featurettes, and other extras. The smaller volumes only feature the plain episodes.


Comments on this article are welcome. You may contact the author from this page:

Contact page


LYRATEK.COM


Read the In-depth Analysis Review for the next story: "The Doctor's Daughter"



Home Page Site Map Star Trek Sliders Doctor Who David Tennant Era Episode Guide Catalogue