Attack of the Cybermen

DVD NTSC
Region 1

DVD PAL
Region 2
VHS Video
NTSC
NTSC
PAL TIN
(Doctor Who Story No. 138, starring Colin Baker)
  • written by Paula Moore
    or, written by Eric Saward under the name "Paula Moore" and repeatedly denied.
  • directed by Matthew Robinson
  • produced by John Nathan-Turner
  • music by Malcolm Clarke
  • 4 episodes @ 25 minutes each, or
    2 episodes @ 45 minutes each
Story: While testing repairs to the TARDIS's chameleon circuit, the Doctor and Peri respond to an alien distress signal and get caught up in a web of intrigue between the original Cybermen invasion of Earth from Mondas in 1986, and a secret project being undertaken from their secondary base on the planet Telos. Understanding how the mercenary Lytton fits into the puzzle may keep the Doctor guessing until the end....

DVD Extras include:

  • Audio commentary by actors Colin Baker (The Doctor), Nicola Bryant (Peri), Terry Molloy (Russell), and Sarah Berger (Rost).
  • Making-of featurette (27 min.) adding script editor (writer?) Eric Saward, director Matthew Robinson, consultant Ian Levine, and
    film cameraman Godfrey Johnson.
  • "The Cyber Story" history of the Cybermen featurette (23 min.), including Cyber Lieutenant Mark Hardy, former director Morris Barry,
    costume designers Sandra Reid and Dinah Collins, and Cyber voice Roy Skelton.
  • "Human Cyborg" interview of Professor Kevin Warwick (8 min.)
  • Isolated Music Score by Malcolm Clarke
  • Pop-up Production Note Subtitles
  • The Cyber Generations - music montage video (8 min.)
  • Photo Gallery

In-Depth Analysis Review

by Martin Izsak

WARNING: This review contains "SPOILERS", and is intended for those who have already seen the program.
To avoid the spoilers, read the Buyers' Guide version instead.


Doctor Who makes a bit of a welcome return to many of its roots with this story, which goes far to help anchor new Doctor Colin Baker into his role. Though not a truly grand story itself, it is a vast improvement on the previous two tales, and though it can hardly be thought of as non-violent, its writer(s) seem to have learned that less excessive amounts of violence actually leave more room for a better focus on story and atmosphere. And even if his relationship with Peri isn't producing a lot of good scenes, Colin Baker has found his characterization of the Doctor here, and that at least is finally working well.


Officially, this is the beginning of season 22, even if the previous story felt more like a beginning. Season 22 is unique for experimenting with one of the biggest format changes ever for Doctor Who. The stories remained more or less the same total length as usual, but were now written and produced to be divided up differently. Instead of 4 episodes per story, at 25 minutes each, the new norm was to be on average 2 episodes per story, at 45 minutes each. Of course, any benefit this experiment had was purely for the show's native British audience, as the 45-minute episodes were again arbitrarily split into 25-minute episodes for sale around the rest of the world. What the rest of us noticed more was that Doctor Who's usually good story structure was being thrown out the window for this season, and it went much deeper than just having weak, unplanned cliffhangers.....

I will continue to automatically refer to the 25-minute versions each time I talk about this season's episodes, unless otherwise specified, since that is the natural format of the classic series that continued uninterrupted in the rest of the world, and it does help highlight many of the problems in the writing for the Colin Baker era.

There are two basic structural problems running through most of season twenty-two, and "Attack of the Cybermen" is probably the story that avoids them both best. The first problem is in the length of time that it takes for the Doctor and Peri to arrive at the scene of the main action and begin interacting with the guest characters. Very often, the international 25-minute Part One will end just as (or sometimes before) our two regulars take their first step out of the TARDIS. It makes one wonder why we needed all those scenes establishing guest characters before our regulars begin to interact with them.

Although "Attack of the Cybermen" still manages to appear to waste a bit of time on a sequence with Halley's Comet which doesn't really get the special effects work to properly complement Peri's reaction to it, this story still looks better than most of the rest of the season's stories regarding the problem of getting to the scene on time, because the Doctor and Peri come out of the TARDIS fairly quickly here. However, it is still a bit of a wild goose chase. They interact with no one before climbing back in, and moving on to a second landing. Although they get a nice beat dealing with two characters we saw before in "Resurrection of the Daleks" (story no. 134), it doesn't really make good story sense that they should still be extras with no dialogue. You'd think the Doctor and Peri would question them as they confront them, but instead they continue nattering between themselves as if the policemen aren't there. Indeed, when Part One ends, the Doctor and Peri have still not yet found any guest characters to talk to yet.

The beats surrounding the TARDIS and its chameleon circuit are a lot of fun though, and the story remains unique in following through on ideas that are only talked about elsewhere in the series. Additionally, the TARDIS gets nicely demonstrated for those who may start watching the show here. Even if it is still one of the usual season 22 delays, the delay is disguised and the sequences are worthwhile this time.

Part One does have one of the best unplanned cliffhangers of the season though. Many mysterious and nasty things have happened to people in the sewers, and as the Doctor and Peri wander off into them, a dark arm shifts into the shot telling us that they are being watched and pursued thus the same is about to happen to them, while the music suggests that this arm belongs to a Cyberman. Too bad there wasn't time to squeeze the next scene into Part One though, because ending on the reveal of the Cybermen probably would have worked better, and cutting to the credits right after Griffiths' scream would have been ideal. I remember I had tried to entice my brother to watch Part One with me when it was first broadcast on TVOntario by letting him know that the title promised that Cybermen were in this story. After the episode he asked me if the Cybermen still looked as good, and I had to think and then say that I hadn't actually seen one yet.


The second structural problem affecting season 22 stories, and probably the more serious of the two, are the anticlimactic endings. Indeed, by the end of the penultimate half-hour episode of most of these stories, we often see the lead villain incapacitated, or worse, and one has to scratch one's head to wonder if there's anywhere left for the story to go for its final half-hour. "Attack of the Cybermen" totally doesn't have that particular problem, and is much more traditionally structured. Indeed, one has to wonder if the storyline took shape on paper before they knew they would be doing 45-minute episodes instead of the usual 25er's.


Some people complain about the amount of continuity references in this story, while others celebrate such things. All good adventures have backstory anyway, and this tale seems equally capable of functioning on its own as an adventure with backstory that just happens to be available to watch in previous episodes. Seeding the plot is a kind of fan-fantasy that the Cybermen should want to revisit the events of "The Tenth Planet" (story no. 29) via time travel and somehow affect a different outcome. Since I believe all outcomes co-exist anyway, this really doesn't make the stakes as big as half the other characters seem to think they are. It really doesn't matter considering what the production focused on putting onto our screens, which was all about moving forward from a completely different old classic story, which the viewer doesn't need to be aware of. In the end, there's only one important thing this story does with the idea spawned from revisiting "The Tenth Planet". Gerry Davis had fudged up the true origins of the Cybermen in his novelizations, and Lytton speaks a line as though he's read those and believed them to be true... only to be corrected by the Doctor. So now, directly in a piece of the show's modern preserved canon, "Attack of the Cybermen" sets the record straight, especially with regards to Telos, neatly vindicating the original TV episodes which were lost and/or unavailable to the public at large at the time. Good job. Cybermen owe a lot of their modern popularity to Eric Saward's passion for resurrecting them respectably.

Other than that, all you really need to know is that the Cybermen have dastardly plans, which depend on using either the stolen time vessel that docks on their tomb-like base on Telos, or alternatively they could use the Doctor's TARDIS instead. Like the Borg invasions seen in Star Trek 8: First Contact, the intricate details aren't too important, as many different avenues for achieving their aims could be argued and fought over, and indeed, many unnecessary complications for this idea were excised from the script long before it went in front of the cameras.

If there is a piece of continuity that you need to know and this story doesn't give you up front, it is largely to get an idea of who those two policemen are in the earliest segments. They have no scenes with Lytton, to whom they have the deepest ties, nor would the Doctor have ever seen them together with Lytton in "Resurrection of the Daleks" (story no. 134). They get passed by a bit too quickly. It is a great pity that they weren't given the ability to have a few lines, such that the Doctor could interrogate them.


Saward Trademarks

While this story does spend much time attempting to relive the series' past, and successfully finds much of its dramatic draw from those elements, that essential atmosphere of family exploration that the series used to have in the sixties (and had again in "Four to Doomsday" (story no. 118) and much of season 19) is now mostly dysfunctional, as the dialogue focuses far too much on the irritability of most of the characters, few of whom one can be morally proud of. Indeed, you will find most of the characters arbitrarily divided up into pairs in this story, and with the exception of pairs of Cybermen villains, there is almost constant arguing and nagging going on between them. It tends to slow the plot down a bit, in addition to being unpleasant to watch. This staple of irritability and blame is actually the seed for the passive-aggressive syndrome that so often defines Eric Saward character arcs. One wonders to what extent he might falsely believe irritability and blame to be universal truths inside every being. While it may be continually debatable how much of this script was written by Saward and how much actually came from Paula Moore / Paula Woolsey, one thing is certain. Saward's trademarks are all over this one.

It is also interesting to note, that of the pairs of characters in the story, the Doctor and Peri often don't seem to be the most important one. Lytton and Griffiths are seen to upstage them at many points, not least of all since they get around to more of the story's settings and interact with more characters, stirring the drink and impacting the plot a bit more, and having more serious confrontations with the main villains. Saward's fixation on mercenaries is in evidence again, and you have to wonder if he didn't think such characters were better at dealing with violent villains, since the Doctor was meant to be such an advocate of non-violence and clearly opposed to guns.

Indeed, much of the Doctor's time on Telos is spent in the prisoner dynamic, which is additionally bizarre considering what he accomplishes during those scenes - forging an alliance with a rebellious Cryon, discovering a means of destroying the base on Telos, and both forming and carrying out the plan that wins at the end of the day. Mind you, I like that he tackles all these things - it keeps the Doctor busy with important tasks. It just really boggles the mind that the script would have him do all this from within the prisoner dynamic. It applies a drag on viewer interest, I think, and really stretches credulity that the Cybermen would lock him up in the same room with explosives and rebel elements, and not do better at confiscating his gadgets.

Once more we see Colin's Doctor aggressively using violence during the final moves of the story, with Saward-style painful screams ringing loudly there as elsewhere in the story. But this is not the "final fix" to resolve the plot, which the Doctor actually set-up earlier in Part Four. This is a separate rescue beat that satisfies the need to give the main character a final confrontation with the lead villains, all while the fate of another important character hangs in the balance. This beat is probably more justified in ending where it does than a similar beat at the end of "Earthshock" (story no. 122), but all things considered, the violence here does loudly overshadow the "rescue" to the point where "Earthshock" still has a much better feel to its ending.

And many fans speculate on what happened with the chameleon circuit at the end of this story, since the TARDIS reverted back to the police box for good here, with no explanation offered. As far as I'm concerned, the chameleon circuit now works, but the Doctor has switched it off after now realizing how much he prefers the exterior the way it was. In essence, the absence of the police box had made the Doctor's heart grow fonder for it. All we know for sure is that he seems pleased that it is back, as most of us fans are too. However, should a future story truly call for something different, by all means turn the chameleon circuit back on for awhile, even if it requires programming the new exterior shape manually. Options are cool.

The Cryons are pretty much the only uniquely new element that this story brings to Doctor Who. They are a fascinating concept for a species, well matched to the story, but sadly the production realized them under the same sort of melodramatic paradigm that previously spoiled many of the creatures from "The Web Planet" (story no. 13). But in many ways, it is very critical that we have them in the story, otherwise we'd have to be very hypothetical about who the Doctor and Peri managed to help in this story. Once again, it seems to be the Saward touch that kills off nearly the entire guest cast of the story, upping the violence and eating into the feel-good value of the adventure. Disappointing.

But I will give this story a very important point back. This is the only Cyberman story of the classic series, beyond the black and white 1960's, that shows the Cybermen converting humans and assorted humanoid species into more Cybermen. This seems to be way too important a part of who they are to be so ignored. Kudos to this story for showcasing it, particularly in the location scene between Lytton, Griffiths, and Bates, which features in both Parts Three and Four of the international version, giving it some good extra exposure.


Maurice Colbourne plays Lytton even better in this story than he did previously in "Resurrection of the Daleks", and the role is written to have more dimension and be more interesting here. Brian Glover also turns out an unforgettable performance as Griffiths, somehow managing to create more viewer sympathy than one would otherwise have expected from reading about a simple petty thug on the page.

Of course, we also have David Banks returning as the definitive Cyber Leader, certainly of this era, but probably of the entire 30+ season franchise as a whole as well I think. And it is just such a lovely mark of respect to bring Michael Kilgarriff back to play the Cyber Controller, after the wonderful work he did elevating the performances of all the Cybermen back in 1967's "The Tomb of the Cybermen" (story no. 37). Granted, Cybermen are realized on screen so differently that audience recognition may be a totally moot point anyway, but Kilgarriff delivers the goods in the role once more under these new challenges, and it is great to have him back.

Malcolm Clarke is of course the perfect choice for scoring another Cyberman story, as many of his excellent tracks from "Earthshock" absolutely deserved the second outing that they receive here, often embellished with new extensions and variations. Opportunities for reusing music from "Resurrection of the Daleks" concerning Lytton's policemen seems to have been another advantage from this choice. But although there are some nice new bits here and there, as with the pseudo "Sanford and Son" style piece introducing the junkyard, or the quotations of Bach's Toccata in "D" Minor that Colin Baker seems to have inspired on the organ, much of the new music is a bit too harsh and primitive for my tastes, particularly most early renditions of Lytton's new theme.
Music by Malcolm Clarke
"March of the Cybermen" (5:13) is available on:
Audio CD - Doctor Who - Earthshock
Silva Screen FilmCD 709

More info & buying options

Not that this is a bad score at all, these are just the reasons why I feel that "The Twin Dilemma" (the previous story) has a better score in terms of new, original material. It is great that Lytton gets a theme though, and it does play in nicer variations as the story progresses. Perhaps best of all in this story are the rich, spooky lead-ins to the Cyber music that feature prominently in the sewer scenes. Clarke is definitely still on form, producing some of the best music ever for Doctor Who.


While "Attack of the Cybermen" certainly indulges in some of the shortcomings that affected this entire era, causing fans to point elsewhere when looking for the show's most excellent stories, this is most definitely one of the better stories of season 22 and the Colin Baker era as a whole. What this story does have going for it is a lot of action, special effects, slight mythological advancement for the series, and a richly layered soundtrack, making it enjoyable nonetheless.



This story has become available on DVD and VHS video.
Click on the Amazon symbol for the location nearest you for pricing and availability:
DVD NTSC Region 1
for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
DVD PAL Region 2
for the U.K.
VHS Video
NTSC in the U.S.
NTSC in Canada
PAL (bundled with "The Tenth Planet" in the U.K.)

Comments on this article are welcome. You may contact the author from this page:

Contact page


LYRATEK.COM


Read the In-depth Analysis Review for the next story: "Vengeance on Varos"



Home Page Site Map Star Trek Sliders Doctor Who Colin Baker Era Episode Guide Catalogue