Black Orchid

DVD NTSC
Region 1

DVD PAL
Region 2
VHS Video
NTSC A
NTSC B
NTSC
PAL
(Doctor Who Story No. 121, starring Peter Davison)
  • written by Terence Dudley
  • directed by Ron Jones
  • produced by John Nathan-Turner
  • music by Roger Limb
  • 2 episodes @ 25 minutes each
Story: Landing in England in the 1920's, the Doctor becomes a badly needed player on young Lord Charles Cranleigh's cricket team, and the entire TARDIS crew is welcomed to a masquerade ball at the Cranleigh's estate where Nyssa meets a physical duplicate of herself named Ann Talbot. Meanwhile, a mysterious and dangerous figure lurks in the shadows....

DVD Extras include:

  • Audio commentary by Peter Davison (The Doctor), Sarah Sutton (Nyssa / Ann), Janet Fielding (Tegan), and Matthew Waterhouse (Adric).
  • "Now and Then" location featurette (9 min.)
  • Costumers and period costumes featurette (8 min.) from "Blue Peter"
  • Deleted scenes (7 min.)
  • Before & after Location film segment restoration featurette (2 min.)
  • Fifth Doctor Comic Strip featurette (16 min.)
  • Viewer reactions to rescheduling (2 min.) from "Points of View"
  • Pop-up Production Note Subtitles
  • Photo Gallery (4 min.)
  • Easter Egg

Buyers' Guide Review

by Martin Izsak

(A more in-depth analysis, containing "SPOILERS" and intended for those who have already seen the program, can be accessed here.)


This little tale is widely known for being the only "purely historical" story since 1966's "The Highlanders" (story no. 31) at the beginning of the Patrick Troughton era. Pure Historicals are a problematic sub-genre in Doctor Who, often having trouble figuring out what they're really all about, and often having even more trouble holding the interest of the show's core science fiction fans.

"Black Orchid" seems to believe that it is a 1925 period murder mystery, but as we shall see, there is very little mystery in the piece. Although featuring many wonderful ideas and enjoyable scenes, one is easily left wondering, "Where's the story?"


The Mostly Pleasant Meandering

Opening with a lacklustre and somewhat confusing sequence of the catalyst murder that should, according to formula, drive the story forward, this event instead is left so far removed from the concerns of all the rest of the characters we see throughout the first episode that it has virtually no impact beyond being a limp opening.

The rest of the characters are occupied mostly with enjoying themselves, rather nicely inviting the audience to do so with them. The series regulars are introduced quite well, and the TARDIS gets its due with a proper materialization to start things off and a scene in the interior console room juxtaposed with the exterior at the train station. The scanner screen gets its due as well. All you could hope for, in theory.

Dialogue during these scenes is not great however, and the characters don't quite seem at their best. Tegan revealing that she's no longer desperate to get back to her stewardess job is a nice touch, but Adric's curiosity about railways doesn't do anything for the audience, unlike a similar scene with Jamie in "The Evil of the Daleks" (story no. 36) which was at least injected with a good dose of humour. Adric and Nyssa would have done much better asking Tegan to explain some of the rules of cricket, so that members of the audience like myself who need a refresher might have a chance at following the game.


Mistaken identity is a staple of the purely historical Doctor Who story, and "Black Orchid" certainly indulges. Thankfully, Sir Robert Muir is a much more open-minded, well-rounded, and enjoyable character than the usual morons the Doctor often had to deal with in Malcolm Hulke scripts in the Jon Pertwee era, and the very kind of character that was so badly needed in "The Time Meddler" (story no. 17). Excellent. But still, there is hardly enough "story" here to make this a good adventure to introduce new viewers to Doctor Who. And the popular JNT idea of the cutaway takes its toll on this story - the entire threat in this tale seems to be based on cutaway scenes.


"Black Orchid" continues to meander along with little apparent purpose. A cricket match ensues, which the Doctor has gotten involved in. Virtually nothing is done to define the two teams playing each other, or create any stakes in the game that are worth following. It's not even kept obvious which team the Doctor is on. The audience is left to shrug their shoulders like Nyssa and Adric and just sit through a sequence that only seems designed to finally make the fifth Doctor's costume look at home. Hooray for the costume.

A lengthy section of visiting and friendly discussion then ensues, while the idea of Nyssa having a double named Ann Talbot is explored. Then we move on to a costume dance party, with the regulars completely enjoying themselves, Nyssa and Ann having an extra bit of fun playfully trying to confuse their identities, and the Doctor off exploring an empty and somewhat dull set of secret passages.

Intercut with all of this throughout episode one are snippets of our villain, as he interacts quietly with a few extras and inanimate objects. Not very effective.


Where the Deuce has the Mystery Hidden Itself?

Mysteries typically work when an event triggers a line of questions and investigations to which everyone desperately wants answers. Typical murder mysteries involve an exploration of the life of the deceased, in attempts to reconstruct his or her final moments, or to find the killer's motive amongst the deceased's relationships. Of course, if human beings cared as much for people before they lose them as they do after them, we could have all that fascinating exploration without the grisliness of murder polluting our stories.

"Black Orchid", however, gets the whole dynamic completely reversed, giving us the murders while failing to trigger much of an investigation or a reason to care. Writer Terence Dudley is relying on the audience to care all on its own.


Eventually, it's the Doctor and friends who have all the questions turned on them and have to prove themselves and their good intentions. Nothing new there; it's an overused part of the formula of the typical base-defense Doctor Who story, not to mention several other types, usually overcome early in a story's first episode or shortly thereafter. "Black Orchid" has left it too late in the day. By the time we get past this, all the villain's secrets are coming out, all before anyone has had any time to ask questions and build up some mystery.

At last the stakes seem to be raising themselves during an action beat, and the Doctor has some critically good things to do in making the outcome better. Well done.


FIRST IMPRESSIONS - IS IT OVER?

On first viewing, I was starting to like Black Orchid and get into it near the end of Part Two. I was full of anticipation for another section of the story to unfold, along with the deeper mysteries of the piece.

The Doctor was given a book and opened it to the first page. I couldn't read what was written there, but it must have been profound, because it triggered Part Two's cliffhanger. Next week, I tuned in eagerly for Part Three and was most baffled and upset to be watching something called "Earthshock", which didn't seem bad at all in itself, but I didn't want to see it yet if it carried on from Parts Three and Four of "Black Orchid" which I'd somehow missed. I wondered if TVOntario had got their tapes mixed up and broadcast the wrong episode.

Only when the season's broadcasting continued with Part Two of "Earthshock" did I look back at "Black Orchid" and realize that I had actually seen all there was of it. My first experience of a Doctor Who story that was NOT four episodes long. Unforgettable.


So not all that great an ending on writer Terence Dudley's part. The most interesting challenges seemed to get the writer's cop-out. It felt unresolved on my confused first viewing, and still feels unresolved now.


Production Values

Roger Limb does the incidental music in this one, beginning the run of his least successful Doctor Who work. Starting off by reusing not the interesting, emotional, recognizable bits of his score from "Four to Doomsday" (story no. 118) but rather the more random, unnotable links and cues, he embellishes these with added high pitched instrumentation that adds little weight to what was already a pretty airy story. The most stand-out element is a three note phrase played with a high piano sound, the last two of those three forming what I call the "semitone drop", also known as the Achilles' Heel of Roger Limb Doctor Who music.

To do a semitone drop, basically you play any note very briefly, and then drop one semitone to hold the note below it for as long as suspense is necessary. The higher your pitch, the sillier it sounds. Bill Murray made fun of something very similar on the piano in "Ghostbusters", commenting that ghosts hate that. So do I.

The cliché is perhaps most at home in the murder mystery setting, hence it isn't too out of place here, and isn't marring a classic in this case. But long story short, "Black Orchid's" incidental score is nothing to write home about. Semitone drops abound all through the uninspired cues, and it never quite makes itself memorable otherwise.

By contrast, the 1920's dance source music tracks from "Debroy Somers' Savoy Orpheans" and "Irving Berlin" easily steal the show musically and create a fun mood for the party scenes, aided by all the excitement Tegan shows for "The Charleston" in particular. Not the best technical recordings, unfortunately, but great stuff nonetheless.

The acting is of a high calibre in this one, with particularly strong performances from Michael Cochrane as Charles Cranleigh, Barbara Murray as Lady Cranleigh, and Moray Watson as Sir Robert Muir. Sarah Sutton is excellent as ever as Nyssa, and great to see in the decidedly different characterization of Ann, but Ann's portrayal gets a bit theatrically phoney when the script turns her into a wimp - the style of the times more than anything else.


All in all, there are a lot of scenes in this story showing the characters enjoying themselves and having light-hearted fun, which is a welcome breath of fresh air. It's particularly nice to see Adric get to enjoy a party and supper at this point in the series.... Even though it doesn't really work as a mystery and isn't particularly gripping, it still remains a lovely little piece that helps balance the offerings of season 19.



This story has become available on DVD and VHS video.
DVD NTSC Region 1
for North America:
in the U.S.
in Canada
DVD PAL Region 2
for the U.K.:
VHS Video
NTSC A in the U.S.
NTSC B in the U.S.
NTSC in Canada
PAL for the U.K.

Comments on this article are welcome. You may contact the author from this page:

Contact page


LYRATEK.COM


Read the Buyers' Guide Review for the next story: "K9 & Company: A Girl's Best Friend"



Home Page Site Map Star Trek Sliders Doctor Who Peter Davison Era Episode Guide Catalogue