My Brother's Keeper

Season 4
DVD Box Set
Region 1 NTSC

Season 4
DVD Box Set
Region 2 PAL
(Sliders Story No. 65, starring Jerry O'Connell)
  • written by Doug Molitor
  • directed by Reza Badiyi
  • music by Danny Lux
  • produced by Edward Ledding, Jerry O'Connell, & Marc Scott Zicree
  • Production # K2816
Story: Quinn is just a little too late to save his double from a serious injury, but lands in more trouble when he is mistaken for his double's clone, and is captured and prepped to donate some of his organs to replace the ones his double has lost....

In-Depth Analysis Review

by Martin Izsak

WARNING: This review contains "SPOILERS", and is intended for those who have already seen the program.
To avoid the spoilers, read the Buyers' Guide to the season instead.

Back in the third season, "Sliders" was following trends and copying featuring films. Now here in the fourth season, "Sliders" is anticipating future trends and doing episodes that feature films will want to copy. Nice twist, and the show is better for it. Today's premise is all about triggering thought and debate on the medical use of clones, a subject that later thrived in the major motion picture "The Island". But here in "Sliders" the concept of doubles adds another whole beautiful twist to it.

Early sections of the story allow the four Sliders to get involved in an interesting and believable way. Later on they get some smart moves with added humour that should start to resolve things, yet logically drag them into even deeper trouble. All good.

Nicely, the story also actually takes time to reacquaint viewers with the concept of doubles, since it hasn't featured too heavily lately, and we will want to build on the concept. Excellent.

Colin is used well in this episode, particularly in having good active relationships with the rest of the team, and getting some things to do on his own and a unique perspective to add to the discussions. Maggie is also fairly busy and useful during this episode, pretty much leading the team in Quinn's absence. Rembrandt also has his share of helpful things to do, most of which surprisingly are off-screen. We're still liking Remmy, but this isn't his strongest showing.

Of course, Jerry O'Connell has three roles to play in this episode, and he makes them all real and interesting to watch. The clone is probably the most difficult one to write for, since so much guesswork is involved in what a person with his history would be like. Perhaps he changes too much during the episode, and develops too quickly. Either way, he is still highly interesting.

Interestingly, it looks like the latest double of Quinn's father now resembles the new one that has been a part of season four's new mythology, and this is the first time that the actor, John Walcutt, actually gets a significantly big part in the present time. The character is by far the most interesting antagonistic role in this story, with the biggest acting challenge, and Walcutt does good work with it. Perhaps his turn around at the end goes a bit too far too fast to remain believable, but if there is sufficient support for it in the episode, the biggest part is definitely the one line he gets where he admits, nearly in tears, that his whole world has collapsed in the past few days, implying that he feels the need to build a new one for himself. Add that to a bit of Stockholm syndrome, and his journey makes sense, even if it occurs a bit too quickly. Further improvement might be to demonstrate exactly what his world is leading up to the opening of the story, as in exactly how he manages to sleep at nights considering what he does. Still, this is definitely one of the most fascinating roles of the story.

We also get Malcolm Jamal Warner, previously of "The Cosby Show", playing a significant guest role here, and it's a nice dramatic change of pace for Warner from sitcom material. Warner's got some really nice speeches in this one expounding on the story's main theme, and he puts a lot of good emotion into it, driving the points home. As a complete character though, it is sad to see victimhood and passive-aggressive syndrome consume him. Though I can see the point of having such a character arc in the story, it seems to be too common a dramatic rut specifically for coloured characters on television and film (as so eloquently expressed by Cuba Gooding Jr.'s on-screen wife in "Jerry Maguire").

The concluding maneuvers fuel a bit of anticipation for being dull and not working so well, simply because such exchanges have been so problematic and unsatisfying before, as seen at the end of "Love Gods", "Time Again and World", "Greatfellas", etc. But although not 100% ideal, this one works better than most others I can remember. There is more depth and philosophical power on display here than just two-sided one-dimensional posturing, and the situation has some believable surprises in it. Plus, they picked a fabulous location to shoot this in, one that looks gorgeous and enhances the feel of what is being attempted here. Nice.

I'm wondering though if all episodes of the season have the same assistant director shooting empty location plates for the wormhole effects shots.... because we continually get ridiculous angles pointing up into the air. The effect itself seems to be a cheaper standard blue whirlpool superimposed on top, instead of something more integrated with its surroundings like we had back in season one. A better angle really would help sell this thing. I will say though, I think the footage for shots traveling inside the vortex itself have improved greatly, and are now much more believable and cool.

Well, this is definitely one of the better episodes of the fourth season of "Sliders", partly in terms of adventure and character drama, but especially in its handling of a thought-provoking issue. Definitely one of the highlights of the season to look forward to.

This story has become available on DVD. Click on the Amazon symbol for the location nearest you for pricing and availability:

Season 4 DVD Box Set
Region 1 NTSC
for the North American market:
in the U.S.
in Canada
Season 4 DVD Box Set
Region 2 PAL
for the U.K.

Comments on this article are welcome. You may contact the author from this page:

Contact page


Read the In-depth Analysis Review for the next story: "The Chasm"

Home Page Site Map Star Trek Doctor Who Sliders Episode Guide Catalogue